Animation does not survive, and that is unavoidable
Say this first, because most converters do not and people find out afterwards.
A GIF can hold many frames and play them in sequence. A PNG holds exactly one and has no concept of time. So converting an animated GIF gives you its first frame as a still image, and there is no setting that changes that. It is a property of the format, not a limitation of this tool.
If you need the motion, a short MP4 is the right answer and will be far smaller than the GIF was. Animated WebP also works on the web, though neither can be written by a browser on its own.